Nestled in the heart of rural Shiawassee County, Michigan, New Lothrop Tavern—known affectionately to locals as Denny’s New Lothrop Tavern—stands as a classic, vibrant embodiment of Midwest hospitality. Situated directly on Genesee Street, this welcoming neighborhood tavern and grill serves as the community’s primary culinary and social hub. It is a place where warm smiles, icy cold beverages, and unpretentious, hearty comfort food come together to create an unforgettable pub experience. Whether you are taking a scenic drive through Mid-Michigan, dropping by after a local high school football game, or seeking a comfortable weekend hangout, this timeless watering hole delivers an authentic taste of small-town tavern culture.
Stepping inside New Lothrop Tavern reveals a cozy yet energetic atmosphere outfitted with traditional tavern entertainment, including a pool table, electronic shuffleboard, Keno, and big-screen televisions. Known far and wide for its extra-large portions, standout specialty olive burgers, customized baked mac and cheese, and a wildly popular Friday Fish Fry, the establishment offers a dining atmosphere where everyone feels like a regular. From family dinners to late-night weekend relaxation, New Lothrop Tavern brings together exceptional service, traditional recipes, and genuine hometown charm.
Welcoming to solo diners, sports fans, local families, and large social groups
Parking Options
Spacious free dedicated parking lot and convenient free street parking
Payment Guidelines
Traditional cash-only establishment with an on-site ATM provided for guest convenience
Why Visit? Key Highlights
The Famous Friday Fish Fry Tradition: A massive regional draw featuring expertly prepared Icelandic cod, sweet yellow perch, fresh walleye, and jumbo shrimp served alongside classic sides like homemade coleslaw, cottage cheese, and fries.
Customizable Loaded Mac and Cheese: A standout comfort dish featuring rich, baked mac and cheese that guests can personalize by adding slow-cooked pulled pork, smoked beef brisket, grilled chicken, savory corned beef, or seasoned burger meat.
Michigan-Style Olive Burgers: A celebrated regional staple crafted with a juicy half-pound beef patty, melted provolone cheese, mayo, and a signature sliced olive blend on a toasted sweet brioche bun.
Authentic Small-Town Hospitality: Highly praised by long-time patrons for its dedicated owners and welcoming staff members who ensure every visitor experiences fast, friendly service.
Pub Games and Evening Entertainment: Offers endless entertainment options for patrons, including pool, shuffleboard, and regular event nights that bring the local community together.
Traditional Cash-Only Charm: Preserving the classic feel of a traditional rural tavern, the establishment accepts cash payments and maintains an easily accessible indoor ATM.
Menu & Food Offerings
Appetizers and Shared Starters
Dish Name
Detailed Item Description
Sampler Platter
A generous combination basket featuring crispy chicken tenders, mini corn dogs, deep-fried mushrooms, and mozzarella sticks served with two dipping sauces
Pulled Pork Nachos
Crisp tortilla chips layered with slow-cooked pulled pork, melted cheese, and tangy BBQ sauce
Beef Brisket Nachos
Tortilla chips topped with tender smoked beef brisket and warm melted cheese sauce
Beef or Chicken Nachos
Loaded tortilla chips piled high with seasoned ground beef or chicken, melted cheese, and classic toppings
Customized Mac and Cheese
Rich, creamy macaroni and cheese baked to perfection with optional additions of pulled pork, brisket, chicken, corned beef, or burger meat
Pretzel Bites
Ten warm, oven-baked soft pretzel bites served alongside warm cheese sauce or zesty marinara
Puff Bites
Ten golden, bite-sized baked dough puffs accompanied by warm cheese sauce or marinara
Three warm flour tortillas filled with your choice of seasoned ground beef or shredded chicken
Jumbo Shrimp Starter
Six succulent jumbo shrimp prepared either deep-fried to golden crispness or lightly grilled
Cheeseburger Sliders
Three tender beef sliders topped with melted American cheese on mini toasted buns
Mozzarella Sticks
Six golden-fried breaded mozzarella cheese sticks served with warm marinara dipping sauce
Chicken Strips Basket
Four crispy, white-meat tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce
Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled flour tortilla stuffed with seasoned chicken and melted cheddar cheese
Crispy Fried Baskets
Choice of classic french fries, thick-cut onion rings, tator tots, deep-fried pickles, mushrooms, pepper jack cheese balls, chili cheese fries, bacon cheese tots, cauliflower, or fried green beans
Sandwiches and Savory Wraps
Item Name
Detailed Item Description
Grilled or Crispy Chicken
Tender chicken breast served on a toasted bun with crisp lettuce, fresh tomato, and mayo
Chicken Club
Choice of grilled or crispy chicken topped with Swiss cheese, smoky bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo
Steak or Chicken Philly
Thinly sliced steak or grilled chicken sauteed with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and melted provolone cheese
Grilled Steak Philly Wrap
Sauteed steak, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and Swiss cheese wrapped tight in a warm flour tortilla
Chicken Wrap
Grilled or crispy chicken stuffed with lettuce, tomato, onion, mixed cheese, and signature boom boom sauce
